Said It Here

How to tile over an uneven subfloor without tearing it up

An uneven subfloor makes tiles crack and shift if they are laid without a flat surface. Fixing low spots with a feather finish patch or self-leveling compound avoids tearing out the old plywood or linoleum entirely.

What people tried

Every workaround mentioned in the threads below. We haven’t tested any of them — and nobody here is claiming they worked.

  1. 1
    Leaving the sound linoleum in place and installing a decoupling membrane like Ditra instead of peeling everything.
  2. 2
    Using a floor patch or skim coat compound to fill low areas
  3. 3
    Sanding seams and floor patches smooth
  4. 4
    Skipping self-leveler and applying floor patch directly to uneven spots
  5. 5
    Accepting normal industry construction variances
  6. 6
    Paying extra to have installers grind down cement or level the surface
  7. 7
    Switching to a different type of flooring such as modern sheet vinyl
  8. 8
    Gluing the LVP down directly
  9. 9
    Gluing underlayment down beneath the flooring
  10. 10
    Waiting for the material to fully cure before evaluating its condition
  11. 11
    Considering uncoupling membranes like Ditra
  12. 12
    Considering cement backer board
  13. 13
    Using a proper transition profile if the tile ends up higher than adjacent flooring
  14. 14
    Filling gouges with Bondo wood filler and sanding
  15. 15
    Tackling the project one room at a time to build momentum
  16. 16
    laying new flooring or carpet over the existing boards
  17. 17
    ripping out the old boards to level joists and install subfloor sheeting
  18. 18
    Manually evening out the subfloor
  19. 19
    Cutting out the damaged sections joist-to-joist and replacing them with new plywood or OSB
  20. 20
    Laying roofing felt, stapling down 1/4-inch underlayment over the top, and laying LVP
  21. 21
    installing glue down vinyl planks
  22. 22
    using sheet vinyl or carpet
  23. 23
    tearing out and replacing rotted subfloor with OSB
  24. 24
    Placing rugs, furniture, and curtains to hide the waviness
  25. 25
    Contacting the contractors board
  26. 26
    Getting an independent home inspection
  27. 27
    Consulting a lawyer
  28. 28
    Using floor leveler
  29. 29
    Jackhammering away part of the slab
  30. 30
    Take a plainer or belt sander to the seam of the subfloor
  31. 31
    Chip up patch material, remove baseboards, undercut door jambs, and staple down new underlayment
  32. 32
    Pouring floor leveler over the existing mosaic and mortar bed if it is mostly sound
  33. 33
    Removing everything down to the floor joists, installing framing sisters, and putting down a new subfloor and underlayment
  34. 34
    Getting site visits and competing proposals from multiple flooring contractors
  35. 35
    Running dehumidifiers and ventilating fans to dry out the slab
  36. 36
    Asking for recommendations and experiences from online communities
  37. 37
    Waiting for the flooring and subfloor to settle over time
  38. 38
    Using construction adhesive to secure rocking spots
  39. 39
    Applying color-matched unsanded grout caulking to hide cracks
  40. 40
    Removing the floor to re-level the underlay and subfloor
  41. 41
    using self-leveler
  42. 42
    shim them to the correct level or replace them with boards that are the correct thickness
  43. 43
    hire a flooring contractor to restore original floors

In their words

Unedited, most upvoted first, each linked to the thread it came from.

I’ve discovered that there are some high/low spots in the subfloor. I now feel like I’m doing more work than I need to.. Do we just us self leveler? Keep filling and sand down peaks? Put a layer of subfloor over it all? I’m so overwhelmed with this so any advice is appreciated.source ↗

cpgoose · r/Flooring · 8 upvotes

Brand new house. Builder says this is within standards. Flooring rep says once there's rugs, furniture, curtains we won't notice. We think it's defective. Are we being unreasonable?source ↗

We are so discouraged, every day we cannot occupy is costing us hard money (paying rent and the mortgage for this house).source ↗

CanoeCrazy · r/Flooring · 7 upvotes

Appreciate someone explaining to me briefly/as a layman what I’m looking at in this room and what the options are.source ↗

Ok_Science5461 · r/Flooring · 6 upvotes

My problem is the adjacent bathroom.source ↗

I see there's a ~1/2"x12" hump in front of the sink and there's NO Way laminate is going to ride over it. I can't use a floor leveler because it will run into the hallway.source ↗

cutting sheet flooring looks like it would be a nightmare.source ↗

Lower-Ad5889 · r/Flooring · 6 upvotes

Hello, I’m trying to install a vinyl floor and don’t know anything lol. I was curious if this subfloor was too uneven and if I should try to get it more level.source ↗

Lilrayrobb · r/Flooring · 6 upvotes

It’s leaning two ways, down and away from our building, plus there is an old landing that is in the mix.source ↗

The new exterior door threshold sits below the slab level, so i think self leveling would only work up to a point.source ↗

bijouxself · r/Flooring · 4 upvotes

In one area, the tile is already broken/missing and there’s a thick gray/cement-like material underneath that is also breaking apart. We want to remove the carpet and eventually install new porcelain tile ourselves, but we’re not sure what we’re looking at underneath the old tile.source ↗

Legitimate-Spite-217 · r/Flooring · 4 upvotes

It's certainly not a rectangle.source ↗

Geralt-of-Rivai · r/Flooring · 3 upvotes

After removing the carpet, I see some areas are uneven and need to be leveled.source ↗

Should i sand down the whole floor to level the uneven edges and then level it or just level the uneven floorboards using the feather finish.source ↗

lampin_larry1 · r/Flooring · 2 upvotes

First off, let it fully cure. Secondly it does look like they may have used a little to much water, thats why its so light in color. It still may be fine tho let it cure and then see whats whatsource ↗

Valuable-Composer262 · r/Flooring · 2 upvotes

I’m just not sure with the size of the room , its use , the cost , and the repair work done in different aged boards on the side it would be worth itsource ↗

Ok_Science5461 · r/Flooring · 2 upvotes

I'm so annoyed because at the advice of my contractor, I went to a flooring supplier and told the sales rep I needed SPC with 6-8mm core thickness.source ↗

Am I totally cooked??!! Our subfloors are not even (old home) and I'm furious.source ↗

throwaway149573 · r/Flooring · 2 upvotes

I removed the carpet from the subfloor and discovered for the most part the floor is even, but there’s a part of it where it’s not. I’ve used feather finish floor patch, but i find it’s not fully leveled yet even after 3 layers.source ↗

Where the seem is between floor boards, it’s a bit higher, so I’m trying to level it on both sides.source ↗

In the picture 1-2, 3-4 5-6 there are still some open gaps under when i check with the leveler when i place it right on the seam. How should i approach this.source ↗

ninjasinpunjab · r/Flooring · 2 upvotes

What can I do to leave it as is and tile over it not disrupting it at all?source ↗

Waterfallsbro · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

Thank you, some places i have may be a 1/4” unevenness. I’ll just used the floor patch.source ↗

lampin_larry1 · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

Am I overreacting on the floor prep for flex lvt? I don’t want to hassle the installers, but also don’t want to have it peel up in 2 years.source ↗

Gato_Grumpo · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

To be clear, they already used compound to level it between the stairs and closet, but it created a bump that I can feel walking over it from the front door direction.source ↗

Gato_Grumpo · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

The underlayment turned out with large white streaks. These are soft and I can press my fingernail into them 16 hours after pour. What will they have to do?source ↗

Independent-Bus601 · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

I’m getting ready to redo my kitchen floor and this will be my first tile installation.source ↗

I pulled up the existing LVP and found what appears to be an old wood plank subfloor with some type of gray material/underlayment over part of it.source ↗

I’m planning to install 12x24 porcelain tile. The hardwood in the adjacent dining room is only about 1/4” higher than the current kitchen subfloor, so I’m trying to keep the tile assembly as thin as reasonably possible.source ↗

Scod420 · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

I’m a bit nervous about subfloor sheeting as opposed to another form of insulation - I’ve read airflow is important in a suspended floor and am not sure if this would be “too good” at insulatingsource ↗

Ok_Science5461 · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

I'm so worried we're stuck with these floors and so mad that I took the sales rep's word for it.source ↗

throwaway149573 · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

I hit two specific spots where the OSB subfloor is actively delaminating.source ↗

The wood is flaking apart, and touching it essentially makes it worse.source ↗

I know the ideal answer is usually to cut out the damaged section joist-to-joist and replace the OSB, but I'm honestly hesitant to cut into it if I can avoid it.source ↗

Ok_Cash8276 · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

I've since added an interior perimeter drain with a sump pump which will hopefully prevent these saturated ground conditions from happening again.source ↗

The slab is uneven, has some past moisture damage (efflorescence), and a few areas where old self-leveler is crumbling/flaking.source ↗

I've been given two very different suggestions which I'm looking to select from.source ↗

YYCMTB68 · r/Flooring · 1 upvotes

Iv been there. Bit off way more than I could chew as a first time diysource ↗

RevolutionarySong848 · r/Flooring

Some spot through out the house, step on it and feel kind of sunk down and rocking.source ↗

Panel with tape cracked after moving living in house for a few weeks, high traffic pathway.source ↗

blu3eyes9069 · r/Flooring

It’s just so easy to tell it’s laid over tile, unsure how to describe it but it moves around in a way the LVP in other rooms doesn’t.source ↗

Is there a way to replace it with different LVP and not have that feeling when you walk on it?source ↗

ThickTelevision2536 · r/HomeImprovement

Where this came up

People with this problem also raised